Courts Update Supreme Court starts hearing the plea filed by Amazon...

Supreme Court starts hearing the plea filed by Amazon over the stay order on status quo over Future-Reliance deal

-

New Delhi Jul 27 (ILNS): The Supreme Court today started hearing the petition filed by Amazon against the Delhi High Court Division Bench order, which had stayed the order of the Single-Judge Bench, directing a status quo on the Future-Reliance deal.

The Bench comprising of Justice Rohinton Fali Nariman and Justice BR Gavai started hearing the arguments today.

Earlier, a Division Bench of the High Court presided by Chief Justice D.N. Patel and Justice Jyoti Singh, while passing the order, had observed that since Future Retail Limited (FRL) is not a party to Arbitration Agreement, prima facie, group of companies doctrine can’t be invoked. It further noted that in preliminary findings, there was no reason to seek a status quo order from the Single Judge.

“Statutory authorities like SEBI cannot be restrained from proceeding in accordance with the law,” the bench said. The division bench also stated that the observations made by it are only prima facie and the single judge shall not be influenced by it while passing its order.

The High Court had passed this order while hearing an appeal filed by Future against an order of the single judge directing it to maintain the status quo on its Rs 24,713-crore deal with Reliance that had been earlier objected by Amazon.

The appeal filed before the Supreme Court states that the High Court “failed to appreciate that orders made under the Act [Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996] are appealable only if there exists a provision under the Act specifically providing for a right to appeal”.

Since the single bench order was passed under Section 17(2) of the act, and there being no provision for appeal under the said section, no appeal would lie against the order. The petitioner further submitted “the High Court, while issuing the Interim Common Order, conveniently ignored the fact that Section 13(1) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 merely provides the forum for filing appeals and does not confer an independent right of appeal. Further, it is the parameters of Section 37 of the Act alone which have to be looked at, in order to determine whether the appeal is maintainable or not.

The petitioner further argued that the High Court while passing the interim order failed to appreciate that the order was issued by the Single Judge of the High Court for the limited purpose of preserving the rights of the parties till the pronouncement of the final orders and after coming to the conclusion that the Respondents have violated the directions contained in the EA Order including on the basis of the Respondents’ own unequivocal submission that would not maintain status quo.
The appeal filed by Advocate Mohit Singh on behalf of Amazon sought a stay on the order of the Division Bench. /ILNS/SS/SNG

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Allahabad High Court asks lawyers in the Hathras case to list facilities provided to victim’s family

Lucknow, Sept 18 (ILNS) The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court on Thursday asked the advocates...

Mamata nephew, wife move Delhi HC to quash ED summons in West Bengal coal scam

New Delhi, Sept 18 (ILNS) Abhishek Bannerjee, MP, All India Trinamool Congress and nephew of West Bengal...

Allahabad HC grants bail to man accused of false promise of marriage, later says he’s willing to marry if she converts.

Allahabad, Sept 18 (ILNS) The Allahabad High Court on Tuesday granted bail to a man accused of...

Gauhati High Court directs state to apprise their action plan to evict encroachers in Lumding Reserve Forest

Gauhati, Sept 18 (ILNS) The Gauhati High Court on September 14 directed the state authorities to apprise...

SC quashes Abetment to Suicide charge against women, as no sign of intentionally instigating

New Delhi, Sept 18 (ILNS):The Supreme Court on September 17, while quashing criminal proceedings and a Non...

NCPCR affidavit in Delhi HC: AltNews post showing pic of minor girl, still exists on Twitter

New Delhi, Sept 18 (ILNS) The National Commission for Protection of Child Rights (NCPCR) informed the Delhi...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you