Courts Update Supreme Court instructs Advocate Mehmood Pracha to apologize in...

Supreme Court instructs Advocate Mehmood Pracha to apologize in CAT contempt case


New Delhi Aug 19(ILNS): The Supreme Court on Thursday instructed Advocate Mehmood Pracha to consider filing an unconditional apology with regard to the plea filed by him against the Central Administrative Tribunal order, which held him for contempt of court.

The bench comprised Justice K. M. Joseph and Justice K S. Ravindra Bhat asked Pracha, “You don’t have the previous history, file a written unconditional apology before the Tribunal, we will consider setting aside the order, whatever has happened has happened, we all commit mistakes.” 

To this, Advocate Pracha replied, “I cannot bring myself to agree to, apologize or regret something which I have not done. It was actually me, who was at the receiving end.” 

“I cannot bring myself to agree to something or apologize for something or regret something which I have not done. It was actually me who was at the receiving end.” 

Justice Joseph said,” We are only trying to tell you that this way of approaching it will sub-serve your interests, as also the interest of justice, maintaining the dignity of the Tribunal… You think about it. Don’t throw it out without contemplation.”

Pracha replied, “Certain things were being said by the Chairman qua this Court as well as the High Court of Uttarakhand and other High Courts also… The only thing I said was that if your Lordships have to observe these things, kindly observe them in chambers.”  

Justice Joseph admonished Parcha, saying, “If such things were being said, you could have brought it separately to the notice of the Court. Two wrongs do not make a right. You are justifying something which you’ve done by saying that something which was wrongly done, therefore, you have been provoked to do this, which, in its own right, is wrong.”

Pracha said, “Could your lordships consider staying the order?”

To this, Justice Joseph said, “Not at this stage. We will hear you and then we will take a call.”

Thereafter, the Bench directed the matter to be listed after a month. 

The incident relates to a case fought by Pracha for Indian Forest Officer Sanjiv Kumar Chaturvedi in the CAT. The principal CAT bench had taken suo motu cognisance, where Chaturvedi, who was on deputation to AIIMS, Delhi, had filed different applications with regards to recording of his Annual Confidential Reports (ACR). Citing instances of unruly and contemptuous behavior on the Advocate’s part, the Tribunal had held him guilty of contempt of court under Section 14 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971./ILNS/KR/SNG


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

NHRC member Justice Kumar draws world’s attention to potable water scarcity in UN meet

New Delhi, Sept 23 (ILNS) The National Human Rights Commission member Justice M.M. Kumar has drawn the...

SC dismisses contempt petition against IAS Rajive Gauba for not providing security to main witness of Nitish Katara murder case

New Delhi, Sept 23, (ILNS) The Supreme Court today declined to issue contempt notice against Cabinet Secretary...

Allahabad High Court announces promotion of Class IV employees in UP Radio Police

Lucknow, Sept 23 (ILNS) The Allahabad High Court directed to promote an employee who is a...

Delhi High Court directs MHA, Ministry of Law & Justice to decide on plea seeking removal of scrapped sections from statute books

New Delhi Sept 22(ILNS): The Delhi High Court asked the Ministry of Home Affairs and the Law...

Porn film case: Supreme Court stays arrest of actor Gehana Vasisth

New Delhi Sept 22(ILNS): The Supreme Court today stayed the Bombay High Court order against Bollywood actor Gehana Vasisth...

Allahabad High Court stays appointment of panchayat assistants, accountants and data entry operators in gram panchayats

Allahabad Sept 22(ILNS): The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court stayed the appointment of Panchayat Assistants,...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you