Courts Update Supreme Court holds, classification between Doctors under AYUSH and...

Supreme Court holds, classification between Doctors under AYUSH and Allopathic Doctors under CHS discriminatory and unreasonable


New Delhi Aug 4(ILNS): The Supreme Court while hearing an appeal filed by the North Delhi Municipal Corporation has held that the classification between the Ayurvedic Doctors covered under AYUSH and Allopathic Doctors covered under Central Health Scheme (CHS) is discriminatory and unreasonable since doctors under both segments are performing the same function of treating and healing their patients.

The Division Bench comprising of Justice L. Nageswara Rao and Justice Hrishikesh Roy after hearing the parties and being inclined to and agreeing with the findings of the Tribunal and the Delhi High Court observed that “The only difference is that AYUSH doctors are using indigenous systems of medicine like Ayurveda, Unani, etc. and CHS doctors are using Allopathy for tending to their patients. In our understanding, the mode of treatment by itself under the prevalent scheme of things does  not qualify as an intelligible differentia.”

The petition has been filed by North Delhi Municipal Corporation challenging the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal that declared that the applicants who are ayurvedic doctors covered under AYUSH are also entitled to the benefit of enhanced superannuation age of 65 years (raised from 60 years),   just like the allopathic doctors.

Senior Advocate, R. Balasubramaniam appearing for the Appellant, contended that the benefit of enhanced retirement age should have been extended only w.e.f. September 27, 2017, as per the AYUSH Ministry’s decision, as there is limited scope for interference on a cut­off date, stipulated by the government. He further contends that the appellants should not be burdened with the liability to disburse the unpaid arrear salary to the respondents.

Opposing the contentions of the appellant the Counsel on behalf of the Respondents argued that the action of the authorities in the treatment of the allopathic Doctors vis­à­vis the ayurvedic doctors was discriminatory and violative of Article 14 of Constitution.

He further argued that there can be no separate service condition in so far as the superannuation age is concerned between allopathic and other category doctors,   particularly when the   AYUSH   Ministry itself on November 24, 2017, has enhanced the retirement age for the non­allopathic doctors w.e.f. September 27, 2017, in tune with the Ministry’s order dated May 31, 2016.

While considering the issue of the age of the superannuation, the Bench has further held that no rational justification is seen for having different dates for bestowing the benefit of extended age of superannuation to these two categories of doctors.

Accordingly, the Court has dismissed the Appeal filed by the NDMC and ordered that the respondent doctors are entitled to their full salary arrears and that must be disbursed, within 8 weeks from that date of the order. Belated payment beyond the stipulated period will carry interest, at the rate of 6% from the date of this order until the date of payment./ILNS/DS/GM/SV/SNG


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Supreme Court refuses PILs on Covid-19 measures due to delay in their listing

New Delhi Sept 16 The Supreme Court on Thursday refused to entertain two PILs seeking directions to...

Supreme Court permits symbolic immersion of Ganesh idols, flays Centre for not abiding by Telangana High Court order

New Delhi Sept 16 (ILNS) The Supreme Court has allowed the symbolic immersion of Ganesh Idol this...

Bombay HC dismisses plea of former Mumbai Police Commissioner Param Bir Singh opposing inquiries against him by Maharashtra govt

Bombay Sept 16 (ILNS) The Bombay High Court on Thursday termed as non-maintainable, the petition filed by...

Delhi High Court grants time to petitioner saying Delhi govt formed Delhi Healthcare Corp without LG approval

New Delhi Sept 16 (ILNS) The Delhi High Court, on Wednesday, while hearing a plea alleging the...

Allahabad High Court asks Uttar Pradesh DGP, SIT members to clarify on police inaction in 2019 Mainpuri teen’s hanging

Allahabad Sept 15 (ILNS) The Allahabad High Court today in the investigation of the case regarding the...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you