Breaking News SC strikes down West Bengal Housing Act as a...

SC strikes down West Bengal Housing Act as a parallel legislation


New Delhi, May 4 (ILNS): The Supreme Court today struck down the state legislation WB-HIRA, being repugnant to the Centre’s legislation RERA. WB-HIRA has, therefore, been declared unconstitutional.
The Housing Industry Regulatory Authority (HIRA) was established under Section 20 of West Bengal Housing Industry Regulatory Act, 2017 and published in the Official Gazette of October 17, 2017 and came into effect on June 1, 2018.

The bench of Justices DY Chandrachud and MR Shah maintained that this was becoming a parallel legislation.

On April 20, the Supreme Court had reserved its order on a plea filed by the Forum for Peoples Collective Efforts (FPCE), challenging the constitutional validity of the West Bengal Housing Industry Regulation Act, 2017.

The Bench stated: “Once Parliament has enacted a law, it’s not open to state legislature to enact a similar law and lift it word to word. Test of repugnancy is clearly established.”

Counsel for the petitioner, Advocate Justine George, opposed the HIRA, because there already was a Centre-enacted law in force (RERA).

He said: “The creation of a parallel regime will amount to a state of absurdity.” He also gave an example that electricity being the subject matter of the concurrent list, the Central government has enacted the legislation called “The Electricity Act, 2003”.

“If state governments are also allowed to legislate and make their own electricity statute, then it will lead to a state of absurdity,” added Advocate George.

Senior Advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, appearing for the State of West Bengal, submitted that state government are in the ambit of the concurrent list, where both the Centre and the State can legislate. He said the state law cannot be rendered repugnant to the Centre’s law, until and unless it is in conflict with the same.

While pronouncing the judgement, Justice Chandrachud stated: “HIRA has enacted a parallel mechanism and it is the same enactment as the Centre. Both the statutes refer to the same entry in the concurrent list in Schedule 7. The third test of repugnancy is that subject matter of State enactment is same to the Central enactment.”

The bench further said, “HIRA occupies the same subject Parliament enacted law. West Bengal has attempted to establish a parallel regime, which is not permissible.”

While declaring the Act as unconstitutional, the Court observed, “Provisions of West Bengal HIRA 1993 Act stood repealed after enactment of the HIRA 2016 Act. Our striking down provisions of 2016 Act will not revive the 1993 Act in any way. We conclude that HIRA being repugnant to RERA is unconstitutional.”
The Bench held, “Section 88 cannot override Article 254. RERA itself deals with municipal issues and is enforced by State governments. Section 88 allows a State law, which will complement the RERA.” ILNS\GM\SJ\RJ


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

NCDRC enhanced the cost imposed on Hinduja Hospital from Rs 25,000 to Rs 3,51,000 for negligent services

New Delhi, Jul 17(ILNS) The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) enhanced the cost of Rs 25000/...

Allahabad HC issues notice to BCI on a PIL seeking to re-frame rules re advocates dress code as per the weather of the country.

Allahabad, Jul 17(ILNS) The Allahabad High Court has issued a notice to the Central Government, BCI and to...

2 defeated BJP candidates file election pleas before Calcutta HC

Kolkata, Jul 17 (ILNS): The Calcutta High Court has issued notices on the...

NGT directs remedial action against DSP Associates, Sonipat for illegal mining and diverting flow of river

New Delhi, Jul 17 (ILNS) The National Green Tribunal has issued directions to the Ministry of Environment,...

Rajasthan High Court orders suspension of cop for separating inter-caste married couple

Jodhpur, Jul 17 (ILNS) The Rajasthan High Court has ordered suspension of a policeman for separating an...

No pilot licence, no permission required for micro drones: Govt proposes simpler Drone Rules, 2021

New Delhi, Jul 16 (ILNS) The Ministry of Civil Aviation (MoCA) has released the updated – The...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you