Uncategorized SC stays Gujarat HC decision to appoint women by...

SC stays Gujarat HC decision to appoint women by replacing male Forest officers


New Delhi, Apr 23 (ILNS) The Supreme Court today issued notice to Gujarat Public Service Commission and others on a plea challenging the judgment of Gujarat High Court in which it had granted relaxation of marks for women who appeared for examination which was held for the appointment of forest officers.

Supreme Court bench of Justice Navin Sinha and Justice Ajay Rastogi stayed the operation of Gujarat High Court order in which it had held that 21 posts of Range Forest Officer (“RFO”) in the State of Gujarat, including posts presently occupied by the Male-Petitioners, shall be vacated and women candidates shall be appointed to the said posts within a period of 4 weeks.

The Gujarat High Court had relied on the Supreme Court Judgment of February 17, 2020 in Secretary, Ministry of  Defence v Babita   Puniya & Others in which the Supreme Court directed grant of Permanent  Commissions to Women, who were engaged in Army in Short Service Commissions (SSC). In its judgement Justice DY Chandrachud quoted on the Constitutional spirit of   equality   without   any   gender   discrimination   in   the   following terms.

“Seventy years after the birth of a postcolonial independent State, there is still a need for change in attitudes and mindsets to recognise the commitment to the values of the Constitution. The Apex court observed that the submissions made in the case were based on sex stereotypes premises on assumptions about socially ascribed roles of gender which discriminate   against   women.   Underlying   the   statement that it is a “greater challenge” for women officers to meet the hazards of service “owing to their prolonged absence during pregnancy, motherhood and domestic obligations towards their children and families” is a strong stereotype which assumes that domestic obligations rest solely on women. Reliance on the “inherent physiological differences between men and women” rests   in   a   deeply   entrenched   stereotypical   and constitutionally   flawed   notion   that   women   are   the “weaker” sex and may not undertake tasks that are “too arduous”   for   them.   Arguments   founded   on   the   physical strengths   and   weaknesses   of   men   and   women   and   on assumptions about women in the social context of marriage and family do not constitute a constitutionally valid basis for denying equal opportunity to women officer.”

Appearing for the Male-Petitioners Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan who was assisted by Advocate on Record Nupur Kumar pointed out that according to Article 335 of the constitution the relaxation in qualifying marks in any examination or lowering the standard of evaluation can only be done for the members of Scheduled castes and Scheduled tribes and not for the reservation to the women.

The petitioners also contended that the selection process began in the year 2010 and they joined service in 2016. The petitioners have been working continuously as Range Forest Officers since the said dates with a clean record after obtaining the required training. To which Justice Navin Sinha said that this matter requires consideration and needs to be heard at length. The Apex Court stayed the operation of Gujarat High Court and issued notices to State of Gujarat, Gujarat Public Service Commission and two others.

The matter will be next taken up after 8 weeks. ILNS/KR/SNG


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

In the age of social media, desecration of the reputation of a public figure has become child’s play. Delhi HC directs Saket Gokhale to...

New Delhi, July 13 (ILNS): The Delhi High Court today directed journalist Saket Gokhale to take down...

PIL in SC seeks stringent rules for rash drivers

New Delhi, Jul 13 (ILNS)A Public Interest Litigation has been filed in the Supreme Court, seeking directions...

Can’t drink muddy and contaminated water, even if it is free, says plea in Delhi HC.

New Delhi, Jul 13 (ILNS)The Delhi High Court today asked the Delhi Government to treat the plea...

Sikkim HC directs state govt to strengthen infrastructure for third wave of Pandemic

Sikkim, Jul 13 (ILNS)The Sikkim High Court while hearing its Suo Moto Public Interest Litigation recently, for...

NGT directs DJB to pay Rs Five Lakh per month to CPCB till they control bad odour from Sewage Treatment Plant

New Delhi, Jul 13 (ILNS) The National Green Tribunal today directed the Delhi Jal Board to pay...

Delhi HC directs journalist Saket Gokhale and Twitter to remove defamatory tweets against former Indian diplomat Lakshmi Puri

New Delhi, July 13 (ILNS): The Delhi High Court today directed journalist Saket Gokhale to take down...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you