Breaking News SC stays Delhi HC order that said IGST on...

SC stays Delhi HC order that said IGST on O2 concentrators was ‘unconstitutional’


New Delhi, June 1 (ILNS): The Supreme Court today stayed the Delhi High Court order which had termed the imposition of IGST on oxygen concentrators which are imported by individuals as gifts from abroad as “unconstitutional”.

The bench led of Justices DY Chandrachud and MR Shah issued notice returnable in four weeks. The Supreme Court has stayed the operation of the Delhi High Court order which had held that imposition of IGST on oxygen concentrators which are imported by individuals and are received by them as gifts [i.e. free of cost] for personal use, is unconstitutional.

The apex court observed that it is a debatable issue whether Article 14 is applicable to matters related to taxation policy.

The Delhi High Court, while holding that the IGST imposed on import of oxygen concentrators for personal use is unconstitutional, had said: “This is a George Floyd moment for the citizens of this country. The refrain is ―I can’t breathe‖, albeit, in a somewhat different context and setting.”

A divisional bench of Justice Rajiv Shakdher and Justice Talwant Singh had noted: “The logical sequitur of this would be that persons who are similarly circumstanced as the petitioner, i.e., those who obtain imported oxygen concentrators as gifts, for personal use, cannot also be equated with those who import oxygen concentrators for commercial use.”

The petition before the High Court was filed by Gurcharan Singh an 85-year-old person challenging the IGST on import of oxygen concentrators as gift for personal use. Singh opposed the 12% IGST imposed on an oxygen concentrator sent as a gift from his nephew in the US.

Senior Advocate Arvind Datar, who was appointed as Amicus Curiae in the matter by the High Court, had submitted: “The right to life encompasses within it, the right to health. The right to health includes within it, the right to affordable treatment. The State has not only a duty but a positive obligation is cast upon it to ensure that the health of its citizens is duly protected.

“While there is no right in law to claim exemption from taxes, however, once the State invokes the provisions of Section 25 (Power to grant exemption from duty)of the Customs Act such delegated legislation can be judicially reviewed,” Datar added.

Whereas, counsel appearing for the state contended, “several measures have been taken which include exemption from customs duty and extension of concessions qua IGST in respect of specified goods imported into the country.

“The imposition of IGST on imported oxygen concentrators, which are gifted, and are for personal use, does not violate Article 21 of the Constitution. If this argument of the petitioner is accepted, it will lead to absurd consequences in as much citizens will attempt to seek exemption from property tax, and food items since both housing and food items have been considered as a facet of the right to life as encapsulated in Article 21 of the Constitution,” counsel for the state added.

However, bench had observed, “The Courts and the State have to adopt a humanistic approach, which, in our view, is a facet of Article 21 of the Constitution. The failure to do so both, by the Court and by the State, would lead to an unbridgeable chasm between law and justice, resulting in, disruption of social order.”

The bench had further directed, “To obviate misuse of the oxygen concentrators, by the petitioner and/or persons similarly circumstanced, she/he/they would have to furnish a letter of undertaking to the officer designated by the State that the same would not be put to commercial use.”ILNS\KR\SJ


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Supreme Court issues notice in plea challenging reservation for OBC, EWS within All India Quota for post-graduate medical courses

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Supreme Court today issued a notice in a plea challenging 27% a plea...

Madhya Pradesh HC dismisses PIL on the location of the school

Madhya Pradesh Sept 17(ILNS): The Madhya Pradesh High Court recently, while observing that those matters are best...

Supreme Court Collegium recommends elevation of 8 judges as chief justices of high courts, transfers of chief justices also on the cards

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Supreme Court Collegium has recommended the elevation of 8 judges as chief...

Supreme Court issues notice on tennis player’s appeal on being denied a job under sports quota

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Supreme Court on Thursday has issued notice to the Jharkhand Public Service...

Delhi High Court asks Delhi Govt to reconsider not allowing the sale, service of herbal hookah

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Delhi High Court today in a batch of petitions filed by various...

“Dalit Girl” was brutally raped by a priest: Police to Delhi HC

New Delhi Sept 17 (ILNS) The Delhi Police has told the Delhi Court that a nine-year-old girl who was allegedly raped and murdered by a priest and...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you