New Delhi, Jun 25 (ILNS) An audit team appointed by the Supreme Court has reportedly found that the Delhi government exaggerated the oxygen requirement in the national capital by more than four times during the April 25-May 10, peak period of the COVID-19 second wave.
However, the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (GNCTD) denied the charge, alleging that BJP leaders have made up the report themselves.
The affidavit, placing the reports on record, was filed by Nipun Vinayak, working as Joint Secretary in the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.
On May 6, during the peak of the second wave of Novel Coronavirus infections, a Bench, led by Justice DY Chandrachud of the top court, had directed the Centre to maintain oxygen supply of 700 MT to Delhi, even as Solicitor General Tushar Mehta had presented experts’ calculation pegging the need to be around 415 MT of LMO.
According to the report of the National Task Force (NTF), the second wave of COVID-19 witnessed a rapid surge in active cases, resulting in a sudden, enormous increase in the requirement of medical oxygen.
Various measures were undertaken by the Central Government in coordination with the State Governments to address this challenge. These were presented in detail to the Subgroup on Oxygen related issues, wherein other expert members of the National Task Force were also present.
It was noted that the demand for medical oxygen saw a sudden increase in April 2021, touching an average of 5500 MTs a day in the third week of April 2021, rapidly increasing to a daily average consumption of 7100 MT in the fourth week of April 2021. This increased further to the highest consumption level of 8943 MTs a day on 9th May 2021.
“As on May 25, 2021, the total daily oxygen allocation made to various States/UTs under the allocation/supply plan was a total of 10,250 MTs. This allocation is more than the daily installed production capacity for liquid oxygen in the country, and the supply for this allocation was made possible by the various interventions,” the report said.
The report mentioned that a formula needs to be developed for the calculation of oxygen requirement for the primary, secondary, and tertiary -level hospitals based on the number of Oxygen beds and ICU beds.
Considering the near simultaneous spike in demand for medical oxygen in the high-burden states, resulting in pressure of heavy demand on the limited manufacturing plants in these areas, it became imperative to additionally tag the rapidly increasing demand for LMO to sources of liquid oxygen in the Steel Plants on the eastern side.
To support the movement of the liquid oxygen from the Steel Plants, a logistical plan that included support from the Air Force and Railways was put in place.
Moreover, considering the continuous need to bolster the oxygen supply in the country, as an urgent measure, a total quantity of 1385 MT of LMO in several consignments have been imported into the country from the UAE, Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, Singapore.
These were made available to NCR Delhi (140 MT), Karnataka (485 MT), Maharashtra (180 MT), Rajasthan (60 MT), Tamil Nadu (200 MT), Andhra Pradesh (200 MT), Kerala (80 MT), Goa (40 MT) and more are in the pipeline for the states as per their need. Additional quantity is also tied up for import through Ultra-Pure Gases for the months of June and July, 2021.
It was highlighted in the report that the Empowered Group on Oxygen was continuously working to ensure installation and commissioning of PSA plants, procurement of oxygen concentrators, oxygen cylinders and ISO containers, in a timely manner.
Private sector is being encouraged to strengthen their manufacturing capacities and public sector units are also exploring means to enhance production through technical interventions. States are also developing comprehensive medical oxygen plans and strengthening the infrastructure for medical oxygen in the public and private sector, it said.
The states of Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Telangana, Uttarakhand, Kerala, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan have finalised such plans till now.
Further, as the interim report of oxygen report Audit in NCT of Delhi headed by AIIMS Director Randeep Guleria informed the Court that Delhi required around 300MT oxygen, the Kejriwal government raised this demand by about four times to 1,140MT.
The task force interim report on Delhi further said that there was gross discrepancy in the actual oxygen use claimed and the calculation of consumption using bed capacity. It further said that the discrepancy in data was because of “a poor understanding of demand calculation”.
It was noted that there were certain hospitals that had reported negative consumption. While some negative consumption may have occurred due to more supplies than use, in some cases, the values were too large to be correct. The actual consumption data was thus again revised after deleting the negative values and replacing deemed erroneous values with recommended consumption values .
In the audit report, it was also pointed out that in the data provided by Delhi Government for consumption from April 29 to May 10, there were no negative consumption values, and the consumption did exceed 350 MT on any of the recent days. However, the possibility of incomplete/underreporting could not be excluded.
“There is a variation in the number of ICU beds and non-ICU beds reported in proforma compared to the total number of around 5500 ICU 14 54 Interim Report on Oxygen Audit of NCT of Delhi beds and over 18000 non-ICU beds, as stated to be functional by the Government of Delhi.
“Requirement of oxygen for balance ICU and non-ICU beds, home isolation, nursing homes and non-COVID healthcare should also be factored in, while calculating the oxygen requirement for NCT Delhi. Certain hospitals have responded that they do not have adequate oxygen supply to meet their daily demand,” it added.
Further, the Petroleum and Oxygen Safety Organisation (PESO) reportedly told the SC-appointed sub-group that the “National Capital Territory of Delhi had surplus oxygen, which is affecting liquid medical oxygen (LMO) supply to other states”. It noted that the situation may lead to a national crisis, according to the news report.
On the other hand, Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia denied the charges, saying that no such report exists. In a press conference here, he said, “The BJP leadership and some Cabinet Ministers have been claiming since morning that the SC-appointed audit team has come out with a report on the oxygen shortage faced by the national capital during the months of May and June.
“The AAP government had a word with the members of the Audit committee. They said they are yet to sign any report on the matter. I challenge the BJP to make the ‘so-called’ report, if any such thing exists, public. The matter is sub-judice in Supreme Court and the BJP should refrain from commenting on it,” he added.