Courts Update Petition in SC challenging grant of Krishna Janam Bhumi...

Petition in SC challenging grant of Krishna Janam Bhumi to minorities through 1968 agreement


New Delhi, Apr 19 (ILNS) A petition has been filed in the Supreme Court, challenging the grant of Krishna Janma Bhoomi to Muslims through an agreement.

The petition, filed by Advocate Manohar Lal Sharma yesterday, contended that by cheating the Hindus, the property of Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust was unauthorisedly compromised and given to the Shahi Eidgah.

In the plea, the Central Government, the state of Uttar Pradesh, the Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust, Kumar Mangalam Birla, Shobhana Bhartia, Siddharth Kumar Birla and the Shri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sansthan have been made parties.

Advocate Sharma urged the apex court to declare that the agreement entered into by the Sri Krishna Janma Seva Sansthan with Shahi Idgah on August 12, 1968 was without jurisdiction, so it is not binding on anyone.

The petition also demanded that the Special Investigation Team (SIT) should be constituted by the Sri Krishna Seva Sansthan to give the property of the Krishna Janmabhoomi and Trust to Muslims without agreement and cheating the Hindus through agreement and the members of the Seva Sansthan, to be prosecuted under various Sections of IPC.

This is the second time that Mr Sharma has reached the Supreme Court in the Krishna Janmabhoomi case. Before this, he had filed a petition in 1998, in which a notice was served, but after that, the petition was dismissed due to his Advocate not appearing on the hearing.

Advocate Sharma has cited all the details of the ownership over the property of Krishna Janma Bhoomi Katra Keshav Deo and the decisions that have come from the Courts from time to time.

The petition further demanded the Supreme Court to order the Central Government and the Government of Uttar Pradesh to deploy Special forces to secure the Krishna Janmabhoomi in Mathura.

In addition, the plea demanded the Supreme Court to direct, with the consent of the Krishna Janmabhoomi Trustees, the Central and Uttar Pradesh Government to acquire and manage the Katura Keshav Deo Krishna Janmabhoomi, Masjid Idgah in Mathura, and its management.

The Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust was formed by Jugal Kishore Birla and the Birla family is a lifetime trustee of the Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust, hence the members of Birla family have been made parties in the petition.

The plea cited various rulings in the District Court of Mathura and Allahabad High Court from 1921 to 1946. It assumed that Katra was under the jurisdiction of Keshav Deo Raja Patnimal and then his successor Rai Kishan Das. On February 8, 1944, Jugal Kishore Birla bought Katra Keshav Deo, including Idgah and Prison, from Rai Kishan Das and Rai Anand Das for Rs 13,400.

The land was registered in the name of Madan Mohan Malviya, Goswami Ganesh Dutt and Bhikhen Lalji Aattrey.  The entire land was occupied by Jugal Kishore Birla. In 1951, Jugal Kishore Birla formed the Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust, which had three conditions. 

First, Katra will be renovated and the temple of Lord Krishna will be built there and the teachings of the Gita will be preached. Second, no part of the property will be given or pledged to anyone. Third, Birla family will be the life trustees of this trust, it cannot be removed.

The petition said that in 1958, Jaydev Dalmiya, who was presently the President of Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP), along with some other people, registered a society called Sri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sansthan in Agra.

The society started renovating Katra Keshav Deo in 1958. In 1964, the Society filed suit in the Court of Mathura and demanded the removal of Idgah. Jugal Kishore Birla died on June 21, 1967.

In 1968, the Seva Sansthan Society held a meeting and appointed Deodhar Shastri as its authorised person, who could sign the Memorandum of Understanding with the Muslims and the Shahi Eidgah Committee. 

Subsequently, in 1968, the Society entered into an agreement with the Shahi Eidgah Committee and handed over the entire management of Idgah to the Muslims. This settlement deed was filed in the Court and on the basis of this, the Society withdrew the suit.

In 1993, Mr Sharma and two others filed suit in the Court of Mathura, demanding the removal of the Seva Sansthan Society, but the Society in its reply to the Court, said that the Society and the Trust are separate legal persons and the Society does not represent the trust. Based on this, Sharma’s case was dismissed. ILNS/SJB/SNG/RJ


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Rotary and Tata Trusts to collaborate in Cancer care, Covid care, Nutrition, Rural Uplift Livelihoods, to supplement efforts towards strengthening the nation

New Delhi, July 14 (ILNS) The Tata Trusts and Rotary today announced a five-year collaboration to scale...

Bar Council of Delhi distributed more than Rs 19 crore to lawyers during lockdown: BCD Chairman Ramesh Gupta

New Delhi, Jul 14 (ILNS) The Bar Council of Delhi is reaching out to the lawyers, who...

NGT flays Haryana over sewage overflow on National Highway-19

New Delhi, Jul 14 (ILNS) The National Green Tribunal has pulled up the state of Haryana over...

SC issues notice to UP govt for going ahead with Kanwar Yatra, amid COVID-19 pandemic

New Delhi, Jul 14 (ILNS) The Supreme Court today took suo motu cognisance and issued notice to the Uttar...

Government decision is unconstitutional, SC strikes down Tribunal Reforms Ordinance,2021

New Delhi, Jul 14 (ILNS) The Supreme Court today struck down the provisions of the Tribunal Reforms...

AP knocks SC doors over illegal use of water from inter-state irrigation projects

New Delhi, Jul 14 (ILNS) The state of Andhra Pradesh has filed a petition before the Supreme Court to...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you