Courts Update For cutting 62 trees, Calcutta HC directs real estate...

For cutting 62 trees, Calcutta HC directs real estate major Emaar to pay a Rs 40 crore penalty, plant 100 trees


Calcutta Aug 3(ILNS): The Calcutta High Court has recently directed real estate group Emaar India Limited to pay a penalty of Rs 40 crore and plant 100 trees for illegally cutting down 62 trees.

A single-judge bench comprised of Justice Rajasekhar Mantha passed this order while hearing a petition filed by Soumitra Kanti Dey.

In this petition, the petitioner has been charge-sheeted under the provisions of Section 11(1) of The West Bengal Trees (Protection And Conservation In Non-Forest Areas) Act on February 27, 2017, and charged with cutting 62 trees under the garb of removing stagnant water.

The petitioner has applied for compounding of the offense in terms of Section 16 of the said Act of 2006. It is submitted that the hacking of trees occurred in course of compliance with a notice of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation to remove stagnant water that accumulated in the property to discourage disease-carrying insects.

The cutting of trees has nothing to do with the removal of accumulated water. Yet under the garb of removing water, as many as 62 trees have been cut. Compounding has also been sought on the ground that the petitioner is a first-time offender and is willing to replant double the number of trees in the said plot or anywhere else that the Forest Department may direct.

“It appears that the owners had intended to construct a seven-star hotel at the said premises. While the entreaties made by the petitioner appear to be attractive, one cannot lose sight of the fact that each tree, totaling 62 in number has left a permanent wound on the environment. Irreparable damage has been caused to society by the conduct of the Petitioner,” the Court observed.

Given the heinous crime committed by this Court the impugned order dated January 05, 2019, does not otherwise call for interference, the Court held.

“However, considering the fact that punishing the petitioner with a limited amount of imprisonment under the 2006 Act would not bring back the trees, compensating the State/Forest Department/Society would be just and fair penalty, penance, and retribution. The compensation shall be used to develop the environment in general and maintenance of better vigil against illegal tree felling,” the Court said.

“The Court is, therefore, inclined to permit compounding of the aforesaid offenses mentioned in the aforesaid charge-sheet only upon payment of Rs 40 crore to the respondents within a period of 15 days from the date. The petitioner and/or the owner of the property M/s. Emaar India Limited would additionally have to plant and ensure the growth of about 100 trees on the said premises at No. 11 Russel Street, Kolkata 700071.

It is made clear that the payment of the said amount would not ipso facto entitle the Petitioner to develop the property. The same would be subject to permission of all the authorities under all applicable Statutes and Rules,” the order said.

With the aforesaid direction, the Court disposed of the writ petition./ILNS/AP/SV/SNG


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Allahabad High Court recalls order listing case of errant advocate before another bench

Allahabad Sept 18(ILNS): The Allahabad High Court recently recalled its order in which it had directed the...

CBI seeks dismissal of a petition for separating Director of Prosecution from the agency, says post enjoys full autonomy in the affidavit

New Delhi Sept 18(ILNS): The Central Bureau of Investigation informed the Delhi High Court that the Directorate...

Supreme Court allows appeal against summons issued to invoke the power under Section 319 CrPC

New Delhi Sept 18(ILNS): The Supreme Court on September 13, while setting aside the summoning order passed...

Allahabad High Court asks lawyers in the Hathras case to list facilities provided to victim’s family

Lucknow, Sept 18 (ILNS) The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court on Thursday asked the advocates...

Mamata nephew, wife move Delhi HC to quash ED summons in West Bengal coal scam

New Delhi, Sept 18 (ILNS) Abhishek Bannerjee, MP, All India Trinamool Congress and nephew of West Bengal...

Allahabad HC grants bail to man accused of false promise of marriage, later says he’s willing to marry if she converts.

Allahabad, Sept 18 (ILNS) The Allahabad High Court on Tuesday granted bail to a man accused of...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you