High Court Ex Gratia Compensation, compassionate appointments to families of Govt....

Ex Gratia Compensation, compassionate appointments to families of Govt. Teachers, says plea in Allahabad High Court


New Delhi, May 21 (ILNS): An intervention application has been filed on 19th may 2021, in Public Interest Litigation matter in-Re Inhuman Condition At Quarantine Centres And For Providing Better Treatment To Corona Positive v. State of U.P..

The application has been filed by Advocates Kartikey Yadav and Naman Issrani, for petitioner Mr. Rahul Gangele, who has been working as a teacher in a private university, Indore from past 3 years. 

The Intervenor has sought the indulgence of the Allahabad High court with the sole purpose of safeguarding of interest and protecting the fundamental rights of the Government teachers & employees  and their the family members and dependents who contacted COVID-19 infection while discharging the election duty during the Uttar Pradesh Panchayat elections held in the State of Uttar Pradesh during COVID-19 pandemic and lost their lives due to Covid. (The PIL matter has been listed for 22nd of May 2021. Vide order dated 17.05.2021 , the bench of Justice Ajit Kumar, Justice Siddharth Verma directed the government to come up with definited report as to how the upgradation of Medical Colleges shall be done in 4 months time. And he Principal of SRN Hospital shall also apprise about the working of Centralized Monitoring System of both Covid and Post Covid Wards including ICUs by the next date fixed by filing an appropriate affidavit in this regard.)

The interevenor in its application states that at the time of surge in Covid 19, Panchayat Elections were conducted between 15.04.2021 to 29.04.2021 and outcome of the elections declared on 2.05.2021. More importantly, thousands of Government Employees and teachers in State of U.P. were assigned election Duty.  

The intervenor has also raised grievance that regardless of the threat to their life and well being posed by the pandemic, the Government teachers and Employees  of the State of Uttar Pradesh were compelled to discharge the election duties at the sole discretion of the Government regardless of the danger it posed to not only their lives but also to the lives of their family members to whom they were to eventually return after elections.

The derelict act  of State of  Uttar Pradesh can be viewed by its decision to grant compensation of  Rs. 30 Lacs only to family members and dependants of government employees who had lost their lives while discharging their election duty.  By another order dated 8.05.2021  the State of Uttar Pradesh has issued a direction vide dated 05.05.2021 which provides for monetary compensation of Rs. 50 Lakhs to the families and dependents of those personnel who have lost their lives in prevention and treatment of COVID-19 pandemic.

It was the obligation of the state to take appropriate measures for ensuring safety of its employees from infection , but on account of failure of State Government to adhere with the COVID 19 Protocol , large numbers of Government employees and teachers contracted with Covid 19 infection while discharging election duty.

The High court of Allahabad vide order 06.04.2021 issued direction to District Administration including Police Authorities to see that no crowding takes place in any place all over the State of U.P. and if it finds that any particular place is likely to get crowded, then it should cordon off that area and see that people do not huddle. This Hon’ble Court specifically directed that the Panchayat Elections should also be conducted in such a manner that no congregation of people takes place. Be it nomination, be it canvassing or be it the actual voting, it should be seen that all COVID-19 protocols are observed. Even after the directions of this Hon’ble Court there is failure on the part of the Government of Uttar Pradesh to adhere to the COVID-19 protocol that such a large number of government employees and teachers suffered from covid-19 infection while discharging election duty.

That vide order dated 7.4.2021, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No.- 10698 of 2021 recorded an undertaking by the State Election Commission that counting will be supervised through CCTV cameras to be installed at the designated counting centers and those who were in charge of the counting centers would be held responsible for any lapse regarding compliance of COVID-19 guidelines. It is thus clear that even after the statement given by the State Election Commission before the Apex Court the state election commission in connivance with the State Government did not adhere to the COVID-19 safety rules and regulations for conducting the elections, thereby avoided to stand by their statement given by them before the Supreme Court of India which is clearly a contempt of court.

The intervenor Rahul Gangele has sought following prayers in his intervention application –

1. Issue writ in the nature of mandamus or any other appropriate order, writ or direction directing the respondents to provide equal treatment to the Government teachers / staff and their dependants / family members as has been done by the State Government in relation to other Government officers / personnel performing COVID-19 duties at the directions of the State Government while deciding ex-gratia compensation and other benefits; and

2. Issue writ in the nature of mandamus or any other appropriate order, writ or direction directing the respondents for awarding additional monetary compensation of Rupees Fifty lakhs to the family members/dependents in respect of default in providing medical facilities to the government teachers who lost their life while discharging their election duty due to Covid-19.

3. Issue writ in the nature of mandamus or any other appropriate order, writ or direction directing to the respondents to consider and provide compassionate appointment to the eligible family members of the government employees who have sacrifice their lives due to covid-19 infection while discharging the election duty.(ILNS)KY


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Supreme Court issues notice in plea challenging reservation for OBC, EWS within All India Quota for post-graduate medical courses

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Supreme Court today issued a notice in a plea challenging 27% a plea...

Madhya Pradesh HC dismisses PIL on the location of the school

Madhya Pradesh Sept 17(ILNS): The Madhya Pradesh High Court recently, while observing that those matters are best...

Supreme Court Collegium recommends elevation of 8 judges as chief justices of high courts, transfers of chief justices also on the cards

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Supreme Court Collegium has recommended the elevation of 8 judges as chief...

Supreme Court issues notice on tennis player’s appeal on being denied a job under sports quota

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Supreme Court on Thursday has issued notice to the Jharkhand Public Service...

Delhi High Court asks Delhi Govt to reconsider not allowing the sale, service of herbal hookah

New Delhi Sept 17(ILNS): The Delhi High Court today in a batch of petitions filed by various...

“Dalit Girl” was brutally raped by a priest: Police to Delhi HC

New Delhi Sept 17 (ILNS) The Delhi Police has told the Delhi Court that a nine-year-old girl who was allegedly raped and murdered by a priest and...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you