Breaking News Delhi High Court dismisses Chirag Paswan plea against Speaker’s...

Delhi High Court dismisses Chirag Paswan plea against Speaker’s recognition of his uncle Paras as LJP Lok Sabha leader


New Delhi, Jul 9(ILNS) The Delhi High Court today dismissed the Lok Janshakti Party leader Chirag Paswan’s plea challenging the recognition of his uncle Pasupati Kumar Paras as the party’s leader in the Lok Sabha by Speaker Om Birla. 

Justice Rekha Palli dismissed Chirag paswan’s plea saying, “It is well settled that the Speaker of the House has a right to settle the affairs of the House.” “I absolutely found no material in the petition. Having been expelled from the party, the respondents 5 MPs of the LJP have a right to remain in the House.”

During the hearing, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta appeared on behalf of the Union of India and objected vehemently on the maintainability of the present writ petition. The SG pointed out, “How could Chirag Paswan file this petition on behalf of the party? He has no authority or right to file this on behalf of the party. There may be other remedies. I am not here to advise. The petitioner is ignorant about constitutional issues.”

Senior Advocate Rajshekhar Rao, who appeared on behalf of the Speaker, submitted that the entire case is a conflict within the party. He said, “What happens outside the Parliament is outside the Parliament.” They said it is an inter-party dispute and the court should not entertain this petition. 

To this, Advocate A.K. Bajpai, appearing for Chirag Paswan, claimed that the respondents cannot claim who shall be the party leader. “They are expelled members of the party,” he said. 

Justice Palli replied, “That is why you can go to the Election Commission and explore your remedies. This petition is not maintainable here.” The Court asked Rao to take instructions and tell the Court about the current position. 

After taking instructions, Rao submitted, “If someone is thrown out of the party and remains in the House or in the party, and has not joined the other party. They are deemed to be the member of that party only which is well settled, according to the Supreme Court judgment. But they can’t contest the next election from the same party, but till then they shall remain in Lok Sabha deemed to be members of that party only.” 

The Court then asked the petitioner, “Is inter-party dispute to be decided by this Court? You can’t challenge the Speaker’s Order. He has given his view prima facie. You seek another remedy if you feel that they have acted wrongly against the party. I want to dismiss it with cost, you tell me how much?”

Having examined the legal position and the facts, emerging from the record. I see no reason to entertain this petition. In these facts and circumstances, the petition deserved to be dismissed,” said the Court. 

Chirag Paswan, the LJP MP from Jamui, had filed a plea in the Delhi High court saying, “The change of leader in the Lok Sabha is the prerogative of a particular party and in the present case, Article 26 of the Constitution of the petitioner no 2 (LJP) provides the Central Parliamentary Board to decide who would be leader or Chief Whip in the House of Assembly.”/ILNS/SNG

Paswan has sought directions to set aside the circular dated June 14, 2021, showing the name of Paras as the leader of LJP Party in Lok Sabha and further direct respondent no. 1 to issue a corrigendum showing the name of Chirag Paswan as the leader of the party.

The plea alleged that none of the petitioners were called or informed about the major action, whereas, the decision was taken on the basis of a letter of the chief whip when the Parliament was not in session.

“The Speaker of the Lok Sabha has acted contrary to practice being followed since long in regard to the appointment of leader, chief whip, whip, etc, which has always been communicated by a political party and it further makes it clear when reference is given defection rule and particularly 2(f), which define the leader in House,” the plea added.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest news

Allahabad High Court recalls order listing case of errant advocate before another bench

Allahabad Sept 18(ILNS): The Allahabad High Court recently recalled its order in which it had directed the...

CBI seeks dismissal of a petition for separating Director of Prosecution from the agency, says post enjoys full autonomy in the affidavit

New Delhi Sept 18(ILNS): The Central Bureau of Investigation informed the Delhi High Court that the Directorate...

Supreme Court allows appeal against summons issued to invoke the power under Section 319 CrPC

New Delhi Sept 18(ILNS): The Supreme Court on September 13, while setting aside the summoning order passed...

Allahabad High Court asks lawyers in the Hathras case to list facilities provided to victim’s family

Lucknow, Sept 18 (ILNS) The Lucknow Bench of the Allahabad High Court on Thursday asked the advocates...

Mamata nephew, wife move Delhi HC to quash ED summons in West Bengal coal scam

New Delhi, Sept 18 (ILNS) Abhishek Bannerjee, MP, All India Trinamool Congress and nephew of West Bengal...

Allahabad HC grants bail to man accused of false promise of marriage, later says he’s willing to marry if she converts.

Allahabad, Sept 18 (ILNS) The Allahabad High Court on Tuesday granted bail to a man accused of...

Must read

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you