A Divisional Bench of Chief Justice DN Patel and Justice Jasmeet Singh had earlier directed WhatsApp and the Central government to file affidavits in the matter.
It also alleged that the new policy further mandated that the person either accepts the new policy in operation, or will lose access to WhatsApp by February 8, 2021.
The affidavit stated, “Petitioners have nonetheless singled out WhatsApp and sought unsubstantiated relief that, if granted, would disrupt all such internet-based applications and websites, as well as the multitudes of ordinary people, who rely on them for a wide variety of services every day.”
“The 2021 Update does not affect the privacy of personal messages with friends and family in any way. Users’ personal messages are and will continue to be protected by end-to-end encryption, which means that neither WhatsApp, nor Facebook can see these messages,” WhatsApp further submitted.
The messaging giant claimed that the petitioners sought direction to improperly stop the 2021 Update without any legitimate factual or legal basis, whereas WhatsApp provides a user consent flow that goes well above industry practice, and is consistent with WhatsApp’s commitment to privacy and transparency.
WhatsApp further stated that if it’s 2021 Update were stopped on the basis of the petitioners’ baseless allegations, it would not only undermine the users’ freedom to contract with a private party such as WhatsApp, but also disrupt an industry, which provides a wide variety of important services to users on the basis of similar policies.
To justify its stand, WhatsApp stated, “A review of the privacy policies of many internet-based applications and websites confirmed that such policies include provisions describing the information they may collect that are similar to – and in many instances much broader than – those in the 2021 Update,” while referring to the privacy statement and policies of applications and companies like Microsoft, Google, Aarogya Setu, Zomato, BHIM, Zoom, Republic World, Ola Cab, Truecaller, Bigbasket, Air India, Government e-Marketplace, IRCTC. ILNS/KR/RJ